On the Democratic side, I think it is going to be interesting. Here are the scenarios I’d be looking for:
1. Obama 2. Clinton 3. Edwards
or
1. Clinton 2. Obama 2. Edwards
I think Obama has to win outright in order to gain momentum into NH otherwise I see him being a perennial second placer in every race after. That second scenario isn’t a typo either. I think if Clinton wins, it will be very close between Obama and Edwards, enough to essentially call it a tie. My hope is obviously for the first scenario because Clinton is awful.
I think beyond Iowa, you are going to see either Clinton run away with it and see second tier candidates fall behind her or Obama wins a couple early primaries and people start to feel the momentum and get beyond that. Obama has to win Iowa and South Carolina outright and place a strong second in NH. I do not think Edwards has the ability to extend beyond Iowa and South Carolina and I do not think he will be the VP candidate again. I also do not think a VP candidate will be picked from the current crop of candidates.
The most likely scenario is Clinton winning and picking a white male as her running mate from her inner circle (sorry Richardson).
On the Republican side, I think we are going to see something surprising in Iowa:
1. Romney 2. McCain 3. Huckabee
This is a huge stretch since McCain isn’t polling at that level at all. I think McCain is going to at least get third place though and I think it will carry him on to win in New Hampshire (with Romney a close second). From there, it will be a three man race (with Rudy entering the fray after the early primaries) but I think that ultimately Rudy pulls out against all conventional wisdom. No way Thompson can pull out of his current slump, Huckabee doesn’t have enough to win it and I think that Romney and McCain can be worn down by Rudy, president of 9/11.
This would be amazing of course since Rudy likely won’t place better than third in any of the early nominating contests. That won’t matter when he wins big on Super Tuesday though.
My preferred scenario is McCain gaining momentum from a surprise showing in Iowa, a win in New Hampshire and to win out on Super Tuesday and become the nominee. Ultimately, I still don’t agree with McCain on everything but I think he is better than the viable alternatives (sorry Paul). The best part about McCain is that he is right on economic conservative values and that is the most important consideration for me personally. None of the other candidates inspire that confidence.
This is not to mention the fact that I would feel very comfortable voting for McCain over Clinton and I think a lot of people would agree. I have already determined that I will not be voting for Rudy and that Mitt doesn’t inspire anything in me to care if he gets elected over Clinton or not. Let’s double that apathy if Democrats nominate someone other than Clinton. In fact, if Rudy is the nominee and someone other than Clinton is the Democratic nominee, I can see myself going blue this election (under the right circumstances of course). And if it is Rudy and Clinton, I am going to be looking at a third party.
It is kind of sick but I am excited. I didn’t think I would be (and I might not be after February 5th) but it is exciting to think of the different possibilities.